Descartes,
in his six meditation, examines the existence of
corporeal things insofar as he is a thinking thing and his body is an
extended thing. In order to prove the existence of material things,
the mind seem to be of use through the imagination. For, in one's
mind, a triangle must exist because of its arithmetic properties such
as it has three sides but also through the imagination which seems to
give a triangle the appearance of truly existing. For one can imagine
the lines connecting the three angles and the space in between them.
However,
when thinking of a chiliagon (a thousand side figure) one can not
imagine the figure but simply understand it logically. Hence,
Descartes is "aware that [he] is in need of a peculiar sort of
effort on the part of the mind in order to imagine, one that [he]
does not imply in order to understand" (p. 48). Meaning, that
one does not need the imagination in order to understand external
bodies for his logical mind can define them as existent through
mathematics.
Therefore,
it could be deduced that the imagination is part of the body, for
it's images come from external corporeal. However, although one could
live without the imagination and the body, one still feel
“particular” sensations (i.e size of the sun) or “less clearly
understood” thoughts (i.e hunger or thirst) but they still may be
false. However, “by means of these sensations of pain, hunger,
thirst and so on, nature also teaches not merely that I am present to
my body in the way a sailor is present in a ship, but that I am most
tightly joined and, so to speak, commingled with it, so much so that
I and the body constitute one single thing” (pg 53). The evidence
of the mind feeling bodily sensations indicate that the two are
tightly related and must both therefore exist as a single thing.
Nevertheless, although body and
mind are closely related they are each an independent thing of one
another. It is evident through the fact that the mind could not be
divided into parts while a corporeal thing can (even in the
imagination). If a limb is taken off our body the mind does not alter
and therefore is independent from the body. The second observation
regards this idea of separation between body and mind, is that
sensation occurs in the nerves and brain but only turn into action
after logic is applied to them. The sensation of pain is not enough
in order to stop it from happening. Instead, Descartes
believes that the sensation of pain “provokes the mind to do its
utmost to move away from the cause of the pain, since it is seen as
harmful” (pg 57). Hence, considering that one
is only a thinking thing, one still has a body. It is separated from
the mind by its being a non-thinking thing while the mind (and
oneself) is the source of our thoughts.
I agree with your blog, in that, it holds that the mind is a nonphysical substance. Descartes clearly identified the mind with consciousness and self-awareness which holds truth to the fact that the body has absolutely nothing to gain or lose whether or not we stop thinking. But if we were talking about the brain which controls body movements that would be a different story. The mind and body are totally separate.
ReplyDeleteI agree with you Afiya mind and body are two different aspects when it cones to life and how we function.But the brain does control our body movements so doesn't that make them one instead of two separate aspects. I think that Descartes is a little confused in his theories at times but he also finds a way to prove his philosophy may be correct in certain ways
ReplyDelete